April Books 22) Anathem, by Neal Stephenson

Well, I’ve ploughed through the almost 900 pages of novel (plus 20-page glossary, plus 25 pages of supplementary material), and I reckon this gets my Hugo vote. (I’ve read all the other nominees except Zoe’s Tale, but given my track record with Scalzi’s writing I’m unlikely to put it at the top of my list.)

At first I thought this was going to be some sort of combination of The Tombs of Atuan, The Name of the Rose and philosophy of science; our hero is a trainee scholar in a rigidly ritualistic academic culture which covers his entire world. But then it turns out that this is a First Contact story, and we have the build-up to a brilliantly described commando raid in deep space. And our hero resolves the problems in his love-life, so the romantic in me was satisfied too.

I particularly enjoyed Stephenson’s playing with words: the honorific “Saunt” drawing on both savant and saint, the “Concent” combining the characteristics of a convent with undertones of concentration and concepts, our hero’s name “Erasmas” echoing most obviously Erasmus but perhaps also Rasselas and others with similar names. There are a lot of neat and witty allusions to well-known concepts in the history and philosophy of science. Erasmas’ home, the Concent of Saunt Edhar, is located at 51.3° north, the same latitude as London, or Greenwich, or indeed Bath where Herschel discovered the planet Uranus.

Stephenson loses marks on a couple of technical points, though. I mentioned last week that he has his polar orbits wrong. Also, like Asimov in The Gods Themselves, he has matter brought into universes where the nuclear forces don’t operate in quite the same way, in which case I would expect the atoms to either collapse or explode, though I suppose there could be some handwaving explanation (or perhaps I’ve misunderstood what “newmatter” is supposed to be).

I expect it will be a tight race between Anathem and The Graveyard Book for the Hugo this year. My vote goes to Anathem.

This entry was posted in Uncategorised. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to April Books 22) Anathem, by Neal Stephenson

  1. ext_85623 says:

    I would argue that Russian military power recovered quite a bit as a result of the BRIC-phase, and if Russia is now post-BRIC, it will be a while before the benefit from this erodes. Of course, a new surge in energy prices could BRIC up the window at any time.

    So we have a challenged Russia with a political system under strain, but which has reorganised its army, topped up its arsenal, and flushed quite a bit of old equipment from its fleets in favour of new. Lovely! And the Americans are cutting back their commitment to NATO.

    Of course, as North-West European offshore wind builds out, a lot of natural gas will be displaced from electricity generation (like gas, wind generation is considered a peaker source). And if the shale gas thing works out, we’re going to have lots of the stuff on hand, so much so that the North Sea basin may end up staying a big exporter, ironically down the same tubes but in the opposite direction.

Comments are closed.