June Books 22) Byzantium! by Keith Topping

There are some aspects of this book that are so awful that I almost wanted to claw my eyes out. It is set in the city of Byzantium (the future Constantinople / Istanbul) in the first century AD. The city’s population appears to be mainly Jewish (divided between Zealots, Christians and those in between), with a Greek minority and a settled Roman ruling class.

It has minarets.

Huge thudding mistakes and discrepancies abound in the Latin phrases (one recurring example – the senior Roman government official in the city lives in the villa praefectus).

And the first century city has minarets.

The presentation of characters’ names is horrendously inconsistent – some are Latinised, some Grecianised, some Hebrew (or possibly Yiddish), and one who is called “Fabulous” (sic).

And he seems to think that there were minarets in the city before the Turkish conquest of 1453, and six centuries before the foundation of Islam.

Even the transcription of the opening of St Mark’s Gospel in Greek is incorrect, which is pretty astonishing as all you have to do is find a copy of Nestlé-Aland – I’ve got one I can lend you if you like. But (as you may have noticed) I keep coming back to the minarets; it’s only one word in one of the book’s rare descriptive passages, but it demonstrates the utter superficiality of the author’s research into the historical setting.

The train-wreck of the author’s attempts at world-building made it difficult to absorb the actual plot, but I did my best. It is set between the first and second scenes of The Romans – it turns out that the Tardis falls off a cliff near Byzantium and the Doctor, Ian, Barbara and Vicki all get separated when they get swept up in a riot in the city. A thinly contrived sequence keeps them separated until the end of the book when they discover the Tardis has been taken to Italy; in the meantime the Doctor has helped the local Christians write the Gospel of St Mark. Topping writes Barbara rather well, Ian very badly, and the Doctor and Vicki tolerably. (There is a framing narrative with Ian and Barbara, now married in 1973, taking their son to a museum where they see Ian’s old sword.) The most memorable of the supporting characters are some nymphomaniac Roman ladies, and that is not saying much.

I am having difficulty deciding whether or not this is the worst Doctor Who book I have read. The only ones that approach it in awfulness are Eric Saward’s novelisation of The Twin Dilemma and Topping’s Telos novella Ghost Ship. In the end I think Byzantium! takes the prize for sheer quantity of awfulness; it is roughly twice as long as the other two combined. I will send my copy to the first person who asks nicely; I have no interest whatsoever in keeping this book in my collection.

One thought on “June Books 22) Byzantium! by Keith Topping

  1. My view on this is Fitzwilliam was the guiding force, but of course he was related to Burghley.

    Maybe the Scots angle in Ulster swings it. Perrot was conciliatory in the end to the MacDonnells and the Irish, both of whom were a thorn in the side of James VI. So Perrot’s continued influence may not have suited the king – James’ subsequent policy in Ulster suggests he was always going to be heavy handed. After the execution of James’ mother in 1585 the way was being cleared for James to succeed Elizabeth, and that was eventually secured by Burghley’s son.

    I haven’t read Turvey’s book, but on balance I would say Burghley was behind it.

    Does Turvey delve into Sir Dennis O’Roghan’s involvement?

Comments are closed.