The playhouse, like the rest of the place, had been built to Ben’s design. From spring onward (and it always seemed to be spring on Bajor), the doors folded back, so that you could play half inside, half outside. The cover of the trees was put to good use too, for when the sun was too hot. In the winter, the place became a snug little shelter, a cozy cabin, where hot chocolate could be drunk, and s’mores consumed. Right now, halfway through spring, the doors stood open, and Deborah’s game spilled out of the playroom onto the grass outside.
This is Una McCormack’s new book, to be published later this month; and in case you needed reminding, she is the Guest of Honour at Novacon this weekend. (I am afraid that this was the last unread book by Una McCormack on my shelves, so if you have just started reading in hopes of more Una-related content, you may have a long wait.)
The Peacemakers is a Deep Space Nine novel, which unfortunately means I’m not the target audience; I have read a spinoff novel by Robert Sheckley, and seen only the two episodes of Deep Space Nine where Sisko and colleagues are beamed back to 2024, but that’s it.
It doesn’t matter, because The Peacemakers is set some time after the end of the stories that we saw (well, that other people saw) on TV, and the central character is not Captain Benjamin Sisko, but his son Jake, an aspiring writer who is undertaking a visit to the conflict-riven world of Cardassia. There’s a lot of stuff in here that I loved. Jake’s experiences as a writer on the convention circuit must surely be partly inspired by the author’s real life observations. There is an intriguing plotline of him being spied on by his own side, and resisting the efforts of others to involve him in politics.
But in particular, the story really gets going with a cryptic archaeological site and an Agatha Christie-style murder mystery, which also ties into the broader issues of cultural appropriation, commemorating the past and dealing with the legacy of conflict. It’s all tied up with the complex and tragic history of Cardassia, which is close enough to some real life situations that I know rather well. But the parallels are left for the reader to observe; there is no sledgehammer symbolism.
All in all I enjoyed this a lot, despite my general ignorance of Deep Space Nine. The Peacemakers is not out yet, but you can order it here.
Incidentally for fans of African history who don’t already know this, Julian Bashir, the doctor in the space station Deep Space Nine, is played by Alexander Siddig, who is a direct male-line descendant of the Mahdi, who defeated the British in Sudan in the 1880s. His first cousin Mariam al-Mahdi is a prominent opposition leader and former foreign minister.
It continues to be Una McCormack week here, and just a reminder that this is because she is the Guest of Honour at this weekend’s Novacon. Back to the Whoniverse again, with two Big Finish plays, one from 2018 and one from 2022.
Red Planets, starring Sylvester McCoy as the Doctor with Bonnie Langford as Mel and Sophie Aldred as Ace, looks at a Britain in 2017 where the Cold War went the other way and people are celebrating the centenary of the October Revolution and the imminent first human landing on Mars; the Berlin Wall was dismantled in 1984 when Western Europe adopted Communism. Meanwhile Ace is in East Berlin in 1961, tangled with a British agent at the jonbar point. It’s quite a complex plot, but well thought through, and the punchline is that the intervention in history comes from quite an unexpected direction.
The main cast, both regulars and guests, are great, but I was not satisfied with the production. I could have done with better cues to indicate which timeline were happen to be in, and there are some oddly long pauses between scenes. It’s also not always clear if the music is diegetic or not. (Though the music by Joe Kraemer is good.) It’s also darker in tone than most Seventh Doctor stories, but that is not necessarily a bad thing. You can get Red Planets here.
F, listening with me in the car, made the point that Doctor Who has hardly ever gone near the real Cold War. He has a point. From the main TV series, the only obvious story is, er, Cold War, set on a Soviet submarine in 1983. In another Capaldi story, Under the Lake / Before the Flood, the military base in was set up to train British soldiers for an invasion of the Soviet in the 1980s, but that’s not hugely relevant to the plot. The worst episode of the Australian K9 series, The Cambridge Spy, is about Soviet intelligence operations in London in 1963. The Russian soldiers in The Curse of Fenric pre-date the Cold War by a few years. (Incidentally, Una McCormack wrote the Black Archive on The Curse of Fenric.)
Someone in the audio commentary makes the sweeping statement that there are few other treatments in any media of what Britain would be like if the Cold War had gone the other way. Actually I can think of some examples, which are both near-future rather than alternate-past because they were written when this appeared an imaginable possibility: Constantine Fizgibbon’s 1960 novel When the Kissing Had to Stop, and the mid-1980s BBC sitcom Comrade Dad. (Nineteen Eighty-Four doesn’t count because Britain is under American rather than Russian domination; The Iron Heel doesn’t count because it pre-dates the Soviet Union.)
The 2022 audio play Torchwood: Infidel Places is also alternate history, of a kind, in that it’s one of a sub-series of Torchwood plays where the main agent for Torchwood during the later Victorian era is, er, Queen Victoria herself, here played by Rowena Cooper. Here she visits Cambridge during the infamous 1897 vote on whether or not women should be allowed to take degrees at the University and finds not only a horrifically misogynist Vice-Chancellor (played by Jon Glover), but also transdimensional demons eating passing academics.
This is the sixth of the seven Torchwood audios featuring Rowena Cooper as Queen Victoria, though the first that I had listened to, and she has clearly got into the stride of it. (She has also made a couple of appearances as Liz Shaw’s mother, Dame Emily Shaw, the Dean of St Matilda’s College, Oxford.) She was 87 when this was recorded, so nine years older than the real Queen Victoria was in 1897, but sounds much more energetic than the real queen would have been. Jade Gordon is also very good as Honora Tapley, the smart young woman who is key to unravelling the mystery. You can get Infidel Places here.
This is alternate history because of course the real Queen Victoria was not in Cambridge fighting transdimensional demons that day – she was in Sheffield opening the new Town Hall as part of her 1897 Diamond Jubilee tour, and, three days before her 78th birthday, was not mobile enough to get out of her carriage in public. However, works of fiction do sometimes include elements that are not true.
It is pretty shocking that Cambridge only allowed women to take degrees in 1948, the last British university to do so, and McCormack rightly displays a bit of sæva indignatio. Between 1904 and 1907, Trinity College Dublin famously awarded degrees to hundreds of “steamboat ladies“, women who had passed their Oxbridge exams but could not have that success recognised by their own university.
Big Finish has actually featured the suffragettes (who get a slightly anachronistic mention here; they are normally said to have kicked off in 1903) in two Companion Chronicles, both featuring the First Doctor and Steven Taylor. One of them is Peace in Our Time, also by Una McCormack, which I wrote up earlier this week. The other is The Suffering, by Jacqueline Rayner, which goes in hard on the oppression of the suffragettes by the state.
One more Una McCormack post to go! And one more sleep until Novacon.
Back in August 2023, I was in London on my way to the Arthur C. Clarke Award ceremony, having been one of the judges that year, and spotted these in Forbidden Planet. We had rewatched Firefly the previous year, and loved it again, so I grabbed the two books; and then ran into the author herself at the ceremony, where she cheerfully signed them.
I confess that I had not actually got around to reading them until now, spurred by the fact that Una is the Guest of Honour at Novacon next weekend, but also they bubbled to the top of my reading lists anyway. One thing to say about both is that at the same time as reading them, I was also attempting to read one of the great classic Western novels set in the general area of Texas in the 1850s, and found the Firefly books so much more entertaining that I abandoned the other one. (More on that in due course.)
Second paragraph of third chapter of Firefly: Carnival:
“Trouble?” said Ava. She wasn’t anticipating trouble. She was heading off to the big city, like she’d always wanted to since Momma and Poppa had died. Free at last! Money in her pocket and all the big wide ‘verse to explore. “I’m a good girl! I ain’t plannin’ on gettin’ into trouble.”
This is set on a planet where the locals are preparing for Carnival, which means hedonistic enjoyment for the rich and hard work for the poor. The Serenity crew get tasked with the delivery of a sensitive cargo, which of course gets stolen from them, as a result of which their client holds Zoe and Shepherd Book hostage against its restitution. The crew also gets entangled with the story of 14-year-old Ava, who has left home to find her fortune in the city. Together they discover much more sinister goings-on, which the alert reader will work out before the characters do (in fairness because the characters are not able to share vital information between each other). We know from TV that human trafficking happens in the Firefly universe, and here we see how deeply it goes. You can get Firefly: Carnival here.
Second paragraph of Firefly: Coup de Grâce:
“Somethin’ the matter, Captain Reynolds?” I said. “Somethin’ you want to say to me?”
Here too there is a young woman at the centre of the story, the daughter of a lawyer who has been assassinated by a local gang. She hires the Serenity crew to get justice for her father, but the local politics turns out to be a lot more complex, with the gang enjoying a certain level of official and corporate protection. We end up exploring both the difficulties of post-conflict social and economic reconstruction, and there is vicious deconstruction of the Boris Johnson government’s “levelling-up” pledges. You can get Firefly: Coup de Grâce here.
Fans of the TV series will be very satisfied with either or both of these books. They both feature very good portrayals of the main cast, and interesting shuffling of the personalities to get pairings where the characters can banter off each other. I slightly get the sense that McCormack’s favourite is Simon Tan, but I may be wrong.
There are seven other Firefly novels, four by James Lovegrove and the others by Tim Lebbon, M.K. England and Rosiee Thor. I have read one book by Tim Lebbon and was on a 2005 Worldcon panel with James Lovegrove; perhaps I need to broaden out my Firefly reading.
Carnival and Coup de Grâce were the two SF books that had lingered longest unread on my shelves. Next on that pile will be Descendant Machine by Gareth Powell, but it will wait until I have finished all the other books I acquired in 2023. Carnival was also the top unread book on my shelves acquired in 2023. Next on that pile is Paul: The Pagans’ Apostle, by Paula Frederiksen.
Two Big Finish Short Trips, both by Una McCormack in advance of her Novacon appearance, both featuring the First Doctor and Steven (the first also with Dodo), both moored in real historical events, both read by Peter Purves. Both are audios, so I won’t attempt to locate the second paragraph of the third section in either case.
This Sporting Life, from 2016, is about the theft of the World Cup thirty years before. Stephen finds himself unexpectedly holding part of the trophy, and the TARDIS crew ends up entangled in a trail of stranded aliens and helpful humans, and the need to get history back onto the right course. The alien intrusion into our history is of course one of the classic Doctor Who plots, but nicely done here, and there are some good character moments for the unsporty Stephen, vs Dodo for whom this is contemporary history. The title of course refers to the 1963 film of the same name starring William Hartnell. You can get This Sporting Life here.
Peace in Our Time, from 2019, is also a story of alien intrusion, but this time it is evil extraterrestrials meddling with the Anglo-German naval arms race by infiltrating the Admiralty just before the launch of HMS Dreadnought in 1906, with the Doctor and Steven trying again to re-route history onto the correct lines. The interesting thing here is that the viewpoint character is Ruby Watkins, a servant in a posh house, who is a channel for McCormack’s observations about class and patriarchy, and ends up (minor spoiler) engaging with the suffragettes. It stretches a bit farther than This Sporting Life, which is not necessarily a bad thing. You can get Peace in Our Time here.
During this brief pause, this hiatus before the whirl of activity that is about to follow, I must take a moment to remind myself how profoundly grateful I am to everyone who has willingly put aside everything to commit themselves to this mission. Above all, I thank the stars for the work done behind the scenes by my new XO, Commander Raffi Musiker. I am aware that through her efforts what should be problems are presented to me as wholly solved. Captain Kirsten Clancy has been liaising with the Romulans, and Raffi is of course a specialist in Romulan affairs. I have the distinct impression that Clancy’s tendency toward micromanagement has been a burden that my XO has also borne on my account, and I am greatly appreciative. This has left me with the time to fully concentrate on staffing, coordinating, and directing the fleet. On Earth, Commander Gbowee has rapidly constructed an organization and processes to respond to our requirements for matériel and staff; she and Lieutenant Kaul are masters of the concise briefing. Messages from Commander Geordi La Forge are proving an interesting read: I sense behind his words some resistance from the yard’s engineers at these new and overwhelming demands that are being placed upon them. I understand too that for many, this will mean setting aside research for many years that may well have been the chief concern. But if any officer can corral them toward a common goal, it is surely Geordi, among the most optimistic, practical, and sincere officers of my acquaintance.
This is the best known book by Una McCormack, according to the three book-logging systems that I consulted. Because Novacon is this weekend, and Una is the Guest of Honour, we’re going to have a run of her novels here this week.
It’s particularly poignant to be writing this so soon after we lost Sir Patrick Stewart. Of course, most of the best lines given to Picard were written by the writers, not him; but there has been a tremendously moving outpouring of affection from those who worked with him, or met him, or just even had a casual encounter with him in the supermarket queue (though I’m not sure that I believe the Huddersfield autograph story). We will not see his like again.
Back in pandemic days, we hugely enjoyed the first series of Picard. This is the prequel, telling the story of how Jean-Luc Picard masterminded the evacuation of the Romulans’ home world on assignment from the Federation. It’s not an action-packed adventure, but a thoughtful exploration of the politics of crisis, with a certain amount of putting narrative pieces in place to explain the setting of Picard.
McCormack folds into this some political parables: the Romulan refugee crisis feeds directly into populism and threats of Brexit-style secession within the Federation; there is a science-denying Romulan nobleman whose refusal to accept the imminent disaster puts his own people in danger. There’s also an interesting depiction of the tensions between secrecy and openness in Romulan society.
But the core of it is the character of Picard, who I think McCormack catches perfectly, and his trajectory from philosophically accepting his duty to losing patience with the Federation, via intermediary stages of indirectly or directly disobeying orders for the greater good. I think even a reader who knew nothing at all about Star Trek would enjoy this. You can get Picard: The Last, Best Hope here.
Novacon is next weekend, with Una McCormack as Guest of Honour. You may not be fully aware of what she has done; writers of tier-in works do not always get the recognition that they deserve. She has published sixteen Star Trek novels, with a seventeenth coming out this month; seven Doctor Who novels, two Firefly novels, two in the shared Weird Space world set up by Eric Green, and a couple of short standalones, as well as more than a dozen short stories. She has also written at least eighteen Big Finish audios, a couple of Blake’s Seven and Star Cops plays and more. She is a critic as well; I list her monograph on a 1989 Doctor Who story below, and she has also edited essay collections on Doctor Who and Lois McMaster Bujold and a collection of meditations from Woman’s Hour.
I give you fair warning that every day of this coming week, this blog is going to feature a review of Una’s work that I have recently read / listened to, culminating with her not yet published Star Trek novel. In the meantime, here is a checklist of her work that I have previously reviewed or mentioned here, followed by the library sites’ ratings of her works as a whole.
“He’s not the Messiah: Undermining Political and Religious Authority in New Doctor Who“, in The Unsilent Library, edited by Simon Bradshaw, Antony Keen and Graham Sleight.
And here is the compete list of her works as far as I can track them on Goodreads, LibraryThing and StoryGraph:
Title
Author
GR raters
LT owners
SG reviews
The Peacemakers
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
not published yet
The Last Best Hope
Star Trek: Picard
4,217
328
759
The Autobiography of Kathryn Janeway
Star Trek: Voyager
2,242
158
538
The Way Through the Woods
Doctor Who
1,302
241
259
The King’s Dragon
Doctor Who
1,144
291
216
Carnival
Firefly
1,604
145
278
Cardassia and Andor
Worlds of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
954
319
136
The Crimson Shadow
Star Trek: The Fall
1,169
185
165
The Never Ending Sacrifice
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
896
216
156
The Way to the Stars
Star Trek: Discovery
983
110
226
Enigma Tales
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
935
113
216
Royal Blood
Doctor Who
821
155
171
Brinkmanship
Star Trek: Typhon Pact
887
150
118
All Flesh is Grass
Doctor Who: Time Lord Victorious
848
85
197
Molten Heart
Doctor Who
589
92
202
The Undefeated
(standalone)
668
78
201
Hollow Men
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
486
218
83
Coup de Grâce
Firefly
939
85
96
The Autobiography of Mr. Spock
Star Trek
604
126
83
Asylum
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
683
60
127
The Missing
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
604
103
82
Wonderlands
Star Trek: Discovery
524
70
110
Second Self
Star Trek: Picard
830
94
22
Caged
Doctor Who
263
26
71
The Baba Yaga (with Eric Brown)
Weird Space
138
50
23
Window on the World
Doctor Who
93
19
27
The Robot Revolution
Doctor Who
73
27
18
Gallifrey: Time War 1
Doctor Who
118
13
20
The Star of the Sea
Weird Space
77
26
15
Partisans
Doctor Who: Gallifrey
90
11
17
Doctor Who: Red Planets
Doctor Who
92
10
16
The Good Life
Doctor Who: Master
79
4
22
The Curse of Fenric
Doctor Who: Black Archive:
33
13
10
Infidel Places
Torchwood
56
4
14
This Sporting Life
Doctor Who
62
3
10
Evolution
Gallifrey
52
3
9
An Eye for Murder
Doctor Who
17
15
4
Peace in Our Time
Doctor Who
47
1
6
Counterstrike
Doctor Who
21
4
5
Impossible Worlds, Impossible Things: Cultural Perspectives on Doctor Who, Torchwood, and the Sarah Jane Adventures (co-edited with Ross Garner and Melissa Beattie)
9
9
3
Ministry of Truth
Blake’s 7
19
19
0
The Shadow of This Red Rock
Star Cops
18
2
6
The Greatest Story Ever Told
(standalone)
11
13
1
Biology and Manners: Essays on the Worlds and Works of Lois McMaster Bujold
4
10
3
Risk Management
Blake’s 7
2
6
4
Troubled Waters
Star Cops
10
3
0
Deliverance
Blake’s 7
8
2
0
Woman’s Hour: Daily Meditat…
1
1
0
Short But Concentrated: an essay symposium on the works of Lois McMaster Bujold (ed with Regina Yung Lee)
0
2
0
Short But Concentrated #2: an essay symposium on the works of Lois McMaster Bujold
I did not get very far with the longer categories in the month between the shortlist announcement on 1 March and tonight’s close of voting. I confess that I was guided by the principle of value for money – the better the ratio of pages to dollars (I get my ebooks from Amazon.com), the more likely I was to read it. The consequence was that I did not read anything like the full ballot in any of these categories.
I list them below in the order of the categories on the ballot paper, which is not the order in the voter booklet (for which many thanks).
I covered Best Audio Fiction and Best Artwork yesterday.
Best Collection
My top vote goes to Uncertain Sons and other stories, by Thomas Ha, a great imaginative collection of twelve mostly fantasy stories about uncertainty and weirdness. The title piece, which ends the book, is the most memorable, with the protagonist carrying around his father’s zombified skull in his backpack for occasional strategic consultations. The second paragraph of the third story (“The Mub”) is:
Somewhere between the black slopes and the longest stretch of the cratered plains, I came across a traveler who I thought might be leaving the city and headed for the nested forests. I greeted him from a distance, just as the road curved around a copse of crooked and dry-skinned pines, but he would not look at me. It was only when we came close to one another that he muttered, “Don’t,” as though throwing the word heavily at my feet, then kept on his way without offering anything else. I’d thought it unkind and almost said something in response.
I also really enjoyed Who Will You Save?, the collection of short stories by Gareth Powell. I enjoyed it more than I expected frankly – 400 pages is quite a lot for a short fiction collection, and many of the stories tie into his other writing, not all of which I am familiar with. But there is a pleasing rejection of formula, or at the vey least some new twists on old stories. Some themes come up several times (teenage love; Bristol) but
The second paragraph of the third story (“Waiting for God Knows”) is:
“It’s an outrage,” Fenrir grumbled over our common channel.
Blood in the Bricks, edited by Neil Williamson, is an anthology of short stories with urban settings heading towards the horror end of the spectrum. The second paragraph of the third story (“Hagstone”, by Tracy Fahey) is:
The yelling is louder. I sigh, fold over the page of the sports section, and get to my feet, grunting out a whoosh of air as I do. Outside, the stark new shapes of industrial units tower over me. The digger is in front of the old half-demolished factory; a rotten tooth in the slick industrial estate. A boy jumps off the digger and runs towards me. Even though the sun beats steadily down, I shiver suddenly; a quick spasm. Goose walking over my grave.
Some of these were very good, including “Hagstone”. But some editorial pruning could have made for a leaner healthier collection; there were too many stories where the protagonist ends up as a human sacrifice to the city’s demons, like The Wicker Man except indoors. You can get Blood in the Bricks here.
I’m afraid that I didn’t get around to the other three nominees, so I will look silly if one of them wins. They are:
The Black Fantastic: 20 Afrofuturist Stories, ed. Andre M. Carrington
Black Friday, by Cheryl S. Nutty
Creative Futures: Beyond and Within, ed. Allen Stroud
(Update: the winner was Blood in the Bricks.)
Best Non-Fiction (Long)
To my surprise, I find that I am voting for Fantasy: A Short History, by Adam Roberts. The second paragraph of the third chapter is long, like most of them:
Two decades later English jurist Henry Sumner Maine, deeply influenced by Carlyle’s writing, published Ancient Law; Its Connection to the Early History of Society, and Its Relation to Modern Ideas (1861). His thesis is that society had shifted from human identity and being-in-the-world as defined by one’s status – one’s place in the social hierarchy, the great chain of being – to our social being and interactions as governed by contracts. In some ways, since contracts (unlike status) can be engaged voluntarily, Sumner sees this as an improvement. But there are losses too, and those losses are what Past and Present is about. Carlyle argues less like a lawyer and more like an artist, and he is certain that what has been lost is reverence, something no contract can bestow: ‘at public hustings, in private drawing-rooms, in church, in market, and wherever else have true reverence, and what indeed is inseparable therefrom, reverence the right man, all is well; have sham-reverence, and what also follows, greet with it the wrong man, then all is ill, and there is nothing’. The contrast Carlyle draws between industrialized irreverential contemporaneity and the vivid life of his imagined medieval world establishes precisely the contrast that the Tolkienian and Lewisian mode of fantasy would later valorize:
Behold therefore, this England of the Year 1200 was no chimerical vacuity or dreamland, peopled with mere vaporous Fantasms, Rymer’s Foedera, and Doctrines of the Constitution, but a green solid place, that grew corn and several other things. The Sun shone on it; the vicissitude of seasons and human fortunes. Cloth was woven and worn; ditches were dug, furrowfields ploughed, and houses built. Day by day all men and cattle rose to labour, and night by night returned home weary to their several lairs. In wondrous Dualism, then as now, lived nations of breathing men; alternating, in all ways, between Light and Dark; between joy and sorrow, between rest and toil, between hope, hope reaching high as Heaven, and fear deep as very Hell.¹
¹Carlyle, Past and Present, 2:1.
This was a really fun and informative read, taking the history of fantasy writing from the very beginning to almost the present day. I am very familiar with the historical structure of the genre, but it was very helpful to see it laid out in such a structured way. Roberts is effusive but also analytical of the writers he admires; he takes no prisoners with the others – on Robert Jordan, for instance:
Manifestly the stylistic inadequacies of these books, their vastness, derivate repetitiveness, do not discourage millions of fans from imaginatively playing in the imaginative theme parks they represent: a wish-fulfilment world more colourful than our own, furnishing an idealized nostalgic past that does not deprive us of present-day bourgeois creature-comforts, parlayed through honest-to-goodness melodramatic emotional intensity.
Often I found myself starting his coverage of one of the series or authors that I have not read thinking “Oh, must try that sometime” and then at the end of Roberts’ analysis thinking “Mmm, maybe not”. There are some annoying typos, and there is almost no coverage of recent writers in languages other than English, but even so I got much more from Fantasy: A Short History than I expected, and it can have my vote in return. You can get it here.
I also really enjoyed Colourfields by Paul Kincaid. The second paragraph of its third chapter is:
It is clear that this volume [The Routledge Concise History of Science Fiction, by Mark Bould and Sherry Vint] is intended as a teaching aid, primarily for undergraduates with little or no previous acquaintance with the genre. In this it works well: it is brisk and breezy, throws in enough theory to seem serious without being weighty, and lets much of the argument rest on the numerous booklists that are embedded throughout the text. The booklists constantly direct the reader outside the text, and while no work that appears in a list is allowed any substantive discussion in the text, taken alone the lists do act as a reasonable if far from comprehensive guide to many of the most significant works of the genre. So, as a starting point for someone coming fresh to the study of the genre, you could do far worse. It’s not perfect, there are inevitably omissions, and the fact that any work discussed in the body of the book is excluded from any list leads to problems, one of the more egregious of which I’ll discuss later. The authors do make every effort to avoid gender or racial bias, making a point throughout the work of discussing books by women or non-white authors equally with those by white males. Though there are moments when this seems to prioritise a minor work by a woman over a major work by a man, in the main this can only be celebrated. With this in mind, it is a pity that, in a genre that is becoming increasingly international, they confine their discussion almost entirely to Anglophone authors. While some authors in translation are unavoidable (Verne, Čapek), authors like Lem and the Strugatsky brothers are mentioned only in a passage about Science Fiction Studies and none of their titles is even listed; others fare even less well.
I stand by what I wrote when I read it a few months ago:
A substantial collection of essays by Paul Kincaid, who is one of the few people to have been both Administrator of the Hugo Awards and a judge for the Arthur C. Clarke Award (the other two are David Langford, and me). They are almost all reviews of other critical works, hence the title, with commentary inserted by the author to contextualise and explain a little more. I had read very few of the books described here, so it made me realise how much more there is to read about sf, and will spur me to add some more to my bookshelves
While I particularly enjoyed the pieces on Brian Aldiss and Ursula Le Guin, I’m afraid I am still unconvinced of the added value of the Marxist analysis of Frederic James and Istvan Csicsery-Ronay, or of the literary merits of M. John Harrison; but maybe that proves Kincaid’s larger point, that there can be no single definition of science fiction, which he pushes in a gentlemanly way. I learned a lot from this, as I had expected. You can get Colourfields here.
It’s a classic collection of pieces by one of our great critics, and deserves to be celebrated.
The only other book that I got hold of in this category was That Very Witch: Fear, Feminism and the American Witch Film, by Payton McCarty-Simas. The second paragraph of its third chapter is:
During this period, witchcraft in the popular imaginary was a fractured signifier. It suggested both sexual empowerment and sexual enslavement; collectivist naturalism and individualistic consumerism; science and superstition; intellectual control and hedonistic abandon. But how could this character come to be a feminist icon, a misogynist boogeyman, a harbinger of religious decline, a sex symbol, a trend, and a joke all at once? Using a number of films from a wide range of different contexts (from studio blockbusters to auteurist art films to pornography to exploitation movies), Part I will trace the history of the countercultural witch film cycle, looking at this figure across her various contexts to suggest that in a decade haunted by questions of belief—in alternative communities and more equitable futures on the one hand and conservative religious and patriotic ideals on the other—the witchʼs evolution as a symbol of mysterious and arcane power reflects these shifting landscapes, particularly in the Womenʼs Liberation Movement. As Jon Lewis put it in his book, Road Trip to Nowhere,
[t]oday the movies from the counterculture era that continue to matter were in their day aberrations, movies that got made despite industry policy, movies made elsewhere (overseas, in the B-industry, by independent contractors working on some half-baked deal with a studio)—movies nobody with money and clout at the time gave half a chance at success.³
³ Lewis, 2022, 3.
I’m afraid I did not get very far; I am just not personally very interested in witch films, and while the author promises to make the connection with wider issues of society and gender, it depended too much on the bits I didn’t care so much about. I am sure that it is a perfectly fine read for those who care more about witch films than I do. You can get That Very Witch here.
The voter booklet (for which, again, many thanks) includes extracts from the other three finalists, enough to make me feel confident in ranking them as follows:
Fantasy: A Short History, by Adam Roberts
Colourfields, by Paul Kincaid
Dispelling Fantasies: Authors of Colour Re-imagining a Genre, ed. Joy Sanchez-Taylor
Writing the Magic, eds. Dan Coxon and Richard Hirst
That Very Witch: Fear, Feminism and the American Witch Film, by Payton McCarty-Simas
Speculation and the Darwinian Method in British Romance Fiction, 1859-1914, by Kate Holterhoff
In my earlier write-up of the shortlists, I noted that the last of these was owned by precisely zero users of Goodreads, LibraryThing or StoryGraph, and is also by some way the most expensive shortlisted book in any category. The extract provided for BSFA voters shows only the most slender of links to science fiction or fantasy literature, and I really wonder why anyone would have nominated it for a BSFA Award, let alone enough voters to get it on the shortlist.
(Update: the winner was Colourfields.)
Best Novel
My sole vote goes to When There Are Wolves Again, by E.J. Swift. the second paragraph of the third chapter (a long ‘un) is:
After the lockdowns, my parents started using my grandparents for free childcare whenever they could get away with it, and I spent a lot more weekends at the house in Herne Hill. This arrangement suited everyone very well with the exception of Gran, who clearly recognized she was being taken for a ride but felt unable to voice her dissent. Grandad and I remained great pals. I could talk to him about anything, and as I got older I talked more and more, and he’d sit and listen. Truly he had the patience of a saint, for he’d smile and ask questions back, and if I finally ran out of things to say, he would think for a while and then dig out some obscure and fascinating fact, like how the sewers worked. As if I were a jay and he were giving me acorns to stash away. My brain has always been a buzzy place, sometimes an overwhelming place. When I was with Grandad, the buzz quietened. He understood that I needed to get things out, or my thoughts might become too much. When I think of Grandad now, I remember his face, and his gentle voice, but mostly it’s the feeling that’s stayed with me. The feeling of being safe.
This is a great novel about the coming ecological catastrophe and the resilience of society in Britain (though we assume that similar stuff is happening elsewhere), told intimately through the story of two women who barely know each other, with the effect of climate change on them and their families delicately portrayed. There is despair, but there is also hope. I feel it really catches the Zeitgeist, and it gets my vote. You can get When There Are Wolves Again here.
(Update: the winner was indeed When There Are Wolves Again.)
The only other book on the shortlist that I have read is A Granite Silence, by Nina Allan. The second paragraph of the third chapter is:
I have always found reassurance in repetition, an aid to thought. Old photographs of Aberdeen docks show a diverse, rambunctious ecosystem teeming with life, a maze of lumber yards and cattle sheds, warehouses and sawmills, a complex, symbiotic machinery geared towards the transport of timber and textiles and livestock, including people. The docks are still busy. Ferries leave for Orkney and Shetland throughout the day. Container ships call at Aberdeen regularly to unload their cargoes. Service vessels bound for the rigs are still based here in the harbour. And the old names are everywhere: Hall, Hood, Duthie and Russell, the great shipbuilding dynasties of Aberdeen’s past embedded in its present, in its street names and parks, carved permanently into the granite from which the town was raised.
It’s an fascinating and well-written book, about the murder of a child in Aberdeen in 1934; Nina Allan takes us in and out of the investigation and weaves different facets of herself into the story, including several breaking-the-fourth-wall moments. I’m giving it five stars on the various book sites.
But I’m not voting for it here, because I don’t think that it qualifies as science fiction or fantasy, and I think that the BSFA Awards should celebrate works of science fiction and fantasy. I know that yesterday I admitted that I am voting for a short story which is about fans of fantasy literature, rather than actually being fantastical itself; but A Granite Silence isn’t even addressing sf or fantasy, it’s a novel about a real life crime with no sfnal subject matter. Congratulations to the author on writing an excellent book, but it does not belong on this shortlist and isn’t getting my vote. Still, you can get A Granite Silence here, and probably should.
For various different reasons I did not read the other three finalists. They are:
Project Hanuman, by Stewart Hotston
The Salt Oracle, by Lorraine Wilson
Edge of Oblivion, by Kirk Weddell
I covered Best Short Fiction, Best Non-Fiction (Short), Best Shorter Fiction and Best Translated Short Fiction yesterday.
Belinda stepped outside the time machine, feeling her pumps scrape against a pavement that her feet did not belong on.
Not that anyone cares other than me, but James Goss has consistently been one of the best Doctor Who prose writers for years, and has never won an award as far as I know.
Once upon a time a long way from Croydon, a child was born, the fifty-fifth child to be born that year in the North Zone in BC-ville. The Nativity Robots decanted her from the amniotic chambers and, with huge smiles upon their chests, duly proclaimed her Sasha 55.
I did not read any of the other three shortlisted books in this category. They are:
Sunrise on the Reaping, by Suzanne Collins
Secrets of the First School, by T. L. Huchu
The Secret of the Sapphire Sentinel, by Jendia Gammon writing as J. Dianne Dotson
I did consider reading Suzanne Collins’ Sunrise on the Reaping, which is far ahead of all the other shortlisted books in any category in terms of public recognition, but it’s 400 more pages and I suspected that there was other stuff on the ballot in other categories that I would enjoy more.
(Update: the winner was Doctor Who: The Robot Revolution.)
Another of the BBC Original audio Doctor Who stories which I have been getting into, one that I particularly selected because I like Una McCormack, both as a person and as a writer, and Clare Corbett has delivered some of the best audio readings that I have heard.
I wasn’t disappointed. This is set in the middle of the recent Fifteen / Belinda series, with the two landing on a planet where two robot bases appear to be at war with each other; meanwhile the bases’ distant human commanders try to work out what is going on before it is two late. At heart it’s a classic story of computers-don’t-argue, but the Doctor and Belinda are captured very nicely by both author and reader, and it’s good to have a bit more time with this sadly short-lived pairing. You can get Counterstrike here.
Once upon a time a long way from Croydon, a child was born, the fifty-fifth child to be born that year in the North Zone in BC-ville. The Nativity Robots decanted her from the amniotic chambers and, with huge smiles upon their chests, duly proclaimed her Sasha 55.
When I watched the TV episode earlier this year, I wrote:
Something didn’t quite gel for me with the first episode, The Robot Revolution. Partly that the plotline wasn’t all that original, but somehow it felt like actors on a set in a way that even early 60s Who didn’t. I was watching it on a cramped screen in a B&B with ants in the floorcracks, so it may not have been the best circumstances, but it really felt like spectacle was being prioritised, and it was one of the weirder introductions for a new companion even by New Who standards.
I am glad to report that I liked Una McCormack’s novelization much more than the TV story; we get a lot more of Belinda’s background and a lot more of poor Sasha 55, and a very good sense of the world of Missbelindachandra as a more-or-less functioning society. It really rounds off the corners of what felt like a slightly hasty TV production. Well worth adding to the shelves. You can get Doctor Who: The Robot Revolution here.
A mixed bag of Companion Chronicle style stories here, though with a strong finish. Released in 2017.
It may just have been the mood I was in when listening to it (generally out of sorts and distracted) but John Pritchard’s “Fields of Terror” failed to click for me. As drama, it is purely Maureen O’Brien wandering the Vendée in the company of a French revolutionary officer played by Robert Hands. I didn’t get into it and the plot didn’t seem to resolve.
The other three are a different matter. “Across the Darkened City” by David Bartlett is a two-hander between Peter Purves as Steven and Nick Briggs as a renegade Dalek. It’s an Enemy Mine situation, with several wrinkles and an unpleasant but shapeless alien menace. It brought me back into the sequence.
And then the third story, “The Bonfires of the Vanities”, with Anneke Wills as Polly and Elliot Chapman as Ben, made me sit up sharply. The TARDIS lands in Lewes on Bonfire Night some time in the 1950s, but it seems that there are dark human forces afoot in the town and dark alien forces out to disrupt the Doctor’s timeline. This was the best of the four for me. I let out a gasp of surprise in the commentary when I discovered that it is by my good friend Una McCormack.
Finally, the same cast are in “The Plague of Dreams”, by Guy Adams, a pre-regeneration story for the First Doctor which invokes Shakespeare in unexpected ways and also brings in a new and unexpected renegade Time Lord, tying in loosely but effectively with the previous story. I felt the second half of this box set generally worked very nicely as a unit.
She’d been trekking for days across the grassy plains that lay beyond the valley and the river and the settlements, but at last the ground was beginning to climb. She was sure she would find answers here.
A rather lovely Fifteenth Doctor novel, with two different sets of cute aliens in potential conflict with each other, and the Doctor and Ruby sorting out the conflict. You won’t get the same level of characterisation here as in Ruby Red, but it’s a good sfnal concept, executed in a very Whovian way. You can get it here.
When I first watched The Curse of Fenric in 2007, I wrote:
The Curse of Fenric had been strongly recommended to me, and I adopted the suggestion that I watch the extended director’s cut version on the DVD rather than the show as originally broadcast (in keeping with the non-sequential traditions of the show, this was actually the last story of the four that I watched, during a three-hour stopover in Ankara airport last Friday).
Well, it is indeed a good story – most memorably, Nicholas Parsons, of all people, playing it straight as the doomed vicar Mr Wainwright; a setting in the second world war that actually looks a bit like it might be the 1940s; vampire villains which now seem an eerie foreshadowing of Buffy; secret codes and ancient evils, and the crucial importance of faith. Indeed, of the four last stories, it is the one which most resembles classic Who at its best.
I was not utterly convinced by the plot; I never like stories which crucially depend on some unbroadcast and untold past adventure of the Doctor’s. And although I did like Tomek Bork’s portrayal of Sorin, I was not totally convinced by the behaviour of the Russian soldiers (and to a lesser extent of the British) – as soldiers, that is. However, in general, this was a good ’un.
When I came back to it for my Great Rewatch, I wrote:
I watched the original version of The Curse of Fenric this time rather than the director’s cut, and noticed only one significant difference – we cannot hear what the Doctor is saying when he makes his profession of faith to ward off the Haemovores, whereas the director’s cut makes it clear that he is reciting the names of all his companions in a litany. It’s another excellent story, with the plot of human conflict being exploited by non-human forces which has a venerable pedigree in Who, and the continuing accumulation of details about what the Doctor may really be up to – and, almost two years after her arrival, more about what Ace is there for – I think only Turlough acquires a comparable amount of back-story in the course of his time in the Tardis, and Ace’s tale works much better. My only quibble about The Curse of Fenric is that I have never been impressed by the Haemovores, whose costumes are a bit cheap-looking to the point that we have to be told to be scared of them by scary music.
Rewatching, I wasn’t quite as impressed as I had been on previous occasions – and I note that both times I had seen it before in the context of the rest of the season; this was the first time I had tried it as effectively a standalone. It feels frankly a bit under-directed; too often the actors are just moving from point A to point B without doing much else, and the cinematography is workmanlike rather than interesting. Also this time around I watched the original TV broadcast, which is not as good as the subsequent edits, and that may have been a mistake. I’m glad that Cartmel was trying to revive the show, but he had not yet got there.
Here’s a weird one for you. Pyramids of Mars, already covered by the Black Archive, and Full Circle, also already covered by the Black Archive, were broadcast on exactly the same calendar dates as The Curse of Fenric: 25 October, 1 November, 8 November and 15 November, in 1975, 1980 and 1989 respectively. The first two were shown on Saturday nights, and The Curse of Fenric on Wednesdays. The day after Episode 3 was shown, the Berlin Wall fell.
When I first read the novelisation in 2008, I wrote:
Ian Briggs, on the other hand, does a masterful job with The Curse of Fenric, perhaps the most adult of any of the Who novelisations (in the sense of talking about sex). The most striking change from the TV original is that the vicar, Mr Wainwright, is explictly young (rather than Nicholas Parsons). Apart from that, the whole narrative feels very soundly rooted both in itself and in Who – particularly with Ace’s introduction in Dragonfire (which of course Briggs also wrote). For once, the Doctor’s-hidden-past motif actually seems to make sense rather than feeling like a bolted-on idea (the only other story that achieves this is The Face of Evil). An excellent read.
Also a comfortable pass for the Bechdel test, what with Phyllis, Jean and their landlady on the one hand, and Katharine, Audrey and the Wrens on the other, with Ace wandering between them.
The second paragraph of the third chapter is:
A thin trickle of villagers, all dressed in their grey Sunday best, were making their way home down the country lane. Only Miss Hardaker, a sharp-faced spinster in her fifties, and two teenage girls lingered on the church porch where the young vicar listened patiently. Miss Hardaker was determined to make her point.
Rereading the novelisation, the same points struck me again; it’s a surprisingly adult book for the range, with the London girls and Ace bantering about sex. And given the timings, it does make more sense for the vicar to be a young man, rather than 66-year-old Nicholas Parsons. There are a couple of good interludes as well, one of which appears to have a drown-up Ace marrying a Russian aristocrat ancestor of Sorin’s. It’s one of the best of the 160+ novelisations.
Both of my Black Archive reads for this month are by writers who I consider friends. Una McCormack is a sparring partner on Twitter:
In this monograph, she has gone for an approach of developing at length four of the interesting themes of The Curse of Fenric, rather than an all-round justification of the story, and as someone who loves the story less than she does, I found it helpful and redemptive. I love most of all the Black Archive books that explain to me why I like some of my favourite Doctor Who stories; but I probably get more out of the ones like this that challenge me to think again about some that are less high up my personal list.
The short introduction sets out her stall, making the link between the timing of first broadcast and the Fall of the Wall, and asserting boldly that “The Curse of Fenric is the best story in what was, at that point, the best season yet of Doctor Who. In other words, I love it.”
The first chapter convincingly positions the story and the entire era in the context of a decade of Conservative government under Margaret Thatcher (who as it turned out would last only another year), and the culture wars waged by government supporters, particularly on and in the BBC. The solution to the chess puzzle of the story is, after all, for the pawns to break ranks and join forces against their common oppressor.
The second chapter points out that this is the first Doctor Who story to explicitly use the Second World War as a setting. (Surprisingly, the Nazis in Silver Nemesis are not named as such.) The war itself is of course a crucial cultural historical experience for the UK, as for other countries. But it’s interesting to look, as McCormack does, at the other later presentations of the war in Who, some of which work and many of which don’t, and to explore the good and bad side of using it as the background for a Who story.
The third chapter looks at Ace as a character, arguing that her arc is the first example of the more modern approach to companions that we have seen in the New Who era, and applying some good feminist analysis to the Doctor and his relations with the women who he tracvels with. The second paragraph of the third chapter, including a quote from Joanna Russ, is:
Russ, in her essay, and in typically acerbic fashion, rapidly sketches and dispenses with the clichés of science fiction: the ‘intergalactic suburbia’ in which the 1950s household remains intact and the woman is wife, mother, and home-maker; the ‘passive and involuntary’ women as prizes or motives for space-faring ‘He-Men’; and the domineering Amazons of matriarchies, waiting to be brought to heel by the arrival of men. Her most illuminating criticism for our purposes, however, is of Ursula K Le Guin’s The Left Hand of Darkness. This novel, published in 1969, a Nebula Award winner and generally accepted to be ground-breaking in its treatment of gender, concerns the inhabitants of the planet Gethen, who have no sex or gender, except that every four weeks they pass through a cycle in which they become either male or female, and sexually potent. The story is motored by the arrival on Gethen of a male human observer, who becomes immersed in Gethenian culture and politics. Russ skilfully argues this is a book from which women are absent:
‘It is, I must admit, a deficiency in the English language that these people must be called “he” throughout, but “put that together with the native hero’s personal encounters in the book, the absolute lack of interest in child-raising, the concentration on work, and what you have is a world of men.’4 4 Russ, ‘Image of Women’, p215.”
The brief short chapter reflects on myth and Doctor Who, and the way in which Cartmel was setting up the Doctor as a mythic figure and using themes from mythology to help tell the story.
I guess my biggest complaint about the book is that it’s a bit short. But you can get it here.