10) Stardust, by Neil Gaiman
A very enjoyable fairy tale by Gaiman. As ever I find myself spotting similarities with Sandman (in this case, the supernatural siblings, and the half-human heir), but I felt he had rung the changes here rather effectively, and the story combines lovely incidental detail with a good sound (if traditional) plot. Great fun. (Wonder if I will get to see the film.)
Girl Genius also got a ton of transfers from Schlock Mercenary (though not so much vice versa in the second-place voting), so there may be something of a webcomic partisanship effect.