Frontios, by Paul Driscoll (and Christopher H. Bidmead)

Frontios is one of the Fifth Doctor stories I caught first time round, back in 1984. I summed up my feelings about it when I watched it again in 2008:

Frontios is fairly standard stuff; I think destroying the TARDIS at the end of the first episode is a bit of a mistake because we know that they must get it back in the end; the Doctor’s concern that the Time Lords might spot him interfering seems a bit belated; as usual for this era, the TARDIS gets used as an interplanetary taxi; while the speaking parts among the guest cast are generally good, the direction of the crowd scenes is pretty lousy; the blokes dressed up in rubber monster suits look like blokes dressed in rubber monster suits (as in most Davison stories); but there is a decent sf story in there, and if you consider it against some of the competition it isn’t so bad.

When I returned for my Great Rewatch in 2011, I wrote:

Frontios is fairly standard stuff [repeating myself], with four memorable but mild demerits: 1) Norna’s very Eighties haircut; 2) the apparent destruction of the Tardis at the end of episode 1, which we know can’t be permanent when there are a bunch more stories to go this season; 3) Turlough’s race memories, which are a well-intentioned but clumsy attempt to inject background into his character; and 4) the trick played on the Gravis by the Doctor at the end, which was written better by Aesop and the unknown originator of Br’er Rabbit.

As it happens I watched this the same week I was listening to the new Big Finish audio, Kiss of Death, which does a lot of the same things (including Turlough’s background and subterranean monsters) and does them better, also with added Nyssa.

(I wince at the fact that both mini-reviews start with the same five words.)

Watching it again now, I was rather impressed by the director’s use of a small studio space to convey a big story, but also even more irritated by Norna’s 1980s haircut than before.

I hadn’t realised that the hapless heir Plantagenet is played by Jeff Rawle, who went on to be George Dent in Drop the Dead Donkey and was also Mervyn Pinfield in An Adventure in Space and Time.

I can see how the story perches on the edge of greatness, but doesn’t quite make it. I also thought that Maurice O’Connell was pretty weak as Cockerill, which is a shame as he seems otherwise to have had a good acting career.

The second paragraph of the third chapter of the novelisation, also by Christopher H. Bidmead, is:

The sound of running feet in the corridor did not disturb him until it stopped outside the door. A man of quick reflexes when the occasion demanded, Cockerill was on his feet before the door opened, the chicken vanished from sight, and he was an alert Orderly attending the return of the leader. But it was not the leader.

I wrote of it in 2008:

I had moderately high expectations of this after reading Bidmead’s other two, and I wasn’t disappointed; this is the best of the Season 21 Fifth Doctor novelisations (though they are not a fantastic batch). I noted for the first time how each of Bidmead’s stories involves a transdimensional threat to the structure of the Tardis, a tinkering with one of the basics of Who which few other writers have attempted. The story works decently enough on the page, though Turlough’s insights into the Tractators could have done with more explanation. An interesting characterisation of the Doctor, absent-minded and failing to tell his companions what is going on.

Worth noting that Bidmead makes the Tractators much less rubber-suit-y on the page, in line with his original vision, which was not brought off by the production. You can get it here.

Paul Driscoll has written one of those Black Archives which attempts to redeem a middling Who story by waxing lyrical about all the things that make it great. I’m sympathetic to the effort, even if I’m not quite sure that it’s worth the efforts that he makes.

A quite substantial Introduction makes the case that the characterisation of the Fifth Doctor had drifted away from Bidmead’s original concept, and that part of the reason he was brought back to write another story was to revisit the character’s roots, much appreciated by Peter Davison himself.

The first chapter, “Thirty Years of Hurt: the Politics of Frontios“, starts with the conflict between the demands of production versus the imagination of the writers, goes on to consider the impact of the war in Lebanon on Bidmead’s thinking, and then settles down to a discussion of Doctor Who and colonialism.

The second chapter, “The Outcasts of the Universe”, looks at monsters, the Tractators’ relationship to woodlice, gravity and trauma.

The third chapter, “Going Underground: Society Breakdown” looks at the symbolism of going underground, and mining. Its second paragraph is:

In the song [‘Going Undergroud’ by The Jam], the underground is a place of retreat and healing. But Weller’s analogy is not short of irony. The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament were quick to point out that instructing the public on how to build a fallout shelter would only make nuclear attack more likely by promoting the mistaken belief that such a war is survivable. Protest groups including the CND sought to expose the ridiculousness of the designs (some of them just a variation on the Second World War Morrison and Anderson shelters) and instructions, such as the message to lie down in a ditch and cover your hands and face if you were unfortunate enough to be outside the home when the warning sounded2.
2 See for example E P Thompson’s parody Protest and Survive, published by Penguin in 1980.

The fourth chapter, “Broken Homes: Family Breakdown”, looks at the TARDIS as a home, and at trauma (again) and bereavement.

The fifth chapter, “Lost Boys: Individual Breakdown”, unpacks the racial memory element of the plot in terms of PTSD.

The conclusion, “The Monsters We Create”, is a spirited defence of Frontios against its critics, pointing out in particular that the dialogue has some very good lines.

It will be clear that I am not completely convince by Driscoll’s arguments, but I enjoy the way he makes them, and if you remember Frontios, you’ll get quite a lot from this. You can get it here.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.