Two Big Finish audios: The All-Consuming Fire and Beware the City of Illusions

I first read the 1994 Seventh Doctor novel All-Consuming Fire, by Andy Lane, in 2008 and hugely enjoyed it.

It melds the worlds of Doctor Who, Sherlock Holmes and Cthulhu and takes us from a mildly steampunky London to a princely state in India, barely dropping a beat. I reread it in 2012 but didn’t feel I needed another go before listening to the audio adaptation by Guy Adams.

And the 2015 adaptation is also very good. Of course it’s quite a long book, so you can’t have everything in a two-hour drama, but the core plot remains with some of the chrome shaved off. Sylvester McCoy as the Doctor feels especially in command, and Nicholas Briggs as Sherlock Holmes and Lisa Bowerman as Benny are on form too. A couple of other notable names in the guest cast: Sam Béart is both the landlady and Azazoth the Elder God (I was seated next to them at the 2024 Hugo ceremony, though in fact I actually spent all of it backstage), and the sinister Baron Malpertuis is played by Anthony May, who way back in 1970 appeared in Here Come the Double Deckers! as the eponymous Pop Singer. Sherlock Holmes’ sinister brother is played by Big Finish veteran Hugh Fraser, who also has a 1970s musical past: he was one of the band Telltale who composed and performed the theme tune to Rainbow.

You don’t need to have read the book to enjoy this, and you can get it here.

I also recently listened to the First Doctor audio Beware the City of Illusions, by Nicholas Briggs, starring Stephen Noonan as the First Doctor, Anneke Wills as Polly and Lauren Cornelius as Dodo and released earlier this year. I was not quite as blown away by this. I do think that Stephen Noonan has settled into the role, and Anneke Wills is great as an older Polly unexpectedly meeting the Doctor out of sequence, so that he does not know her; Lauren Cornelius is confident as Dodo.

The story is a sinister corporation selling its technology to the British government to achieve Net Zero, a sort of updated Claws of Axos, and that’s part of the problem – it’s not terribly original, and really struggles to fill six half-hour episodes. I also found the voices of some of the female actors difficult to tell apart, though that may be just my middle-aged hearing. The First Doctor range has brought some excellent stuff, but I fear this one is not at the top of my list. Still, you can get it here.

The First Doctor Chronicles vol 2

A mixed bag of Companion Chronicle style stories here, though with a strong finish. Released in 2017.

It may just have been the mood I was in when listening to it (generally out of sorts and distracted) but John Pritchard’s “Fields of Terror” failed to click for me. As drama, it is purely Maureen O’Brien wandering the Vendée in the company of a French revolutionary officer played by Robert Hands. I didn’t get into it and the plot didn’t seem to resolve.

The other three are a different matter. “Across the Darkened City” by David Bartlett is a two-hander between Peter Purves as Steven and Nick Briggs as a renegade Dalek. It’s an Enemy Mine situation, with several wrinkles and an unpleasant but shapeless alien menace. It brought me back into the sequence.

And then the third story, “The Bonfires of the Vanities”, with Anneke Wills as Polly and Elliot Chapman as Ben, made me sit up sharply. The TARDIS lands in Lewes on Bonfire Night some time in the 1950s, but it seems that there are dark human forces afoot in the town and dark alien forces out to disrupt the Doctor’s timeline. This was the best of the four for me. I let out a gasp of surprise in the commentary when I discovered that it is by my good friend Una McCormack.

Finally, the same cast are in “The Plague of Dreams”, by Guy Adams, a pre-regeneration story for the First Doctor which invokes Shakespeare in unexpected ways and also brings in a new and unexpected renegade Time Lord, tying in loosely but effectively with the previous story. I felt the second half of this box set generally worked very nicely as a unit.

You can get it here.