Firefly: Carnival and Firefly: Coup de Grâce, by Una McCormack

Back in August 2023, I was in London on my way to the Arthur C. Clarke Award ceremony, having been one of the judges that year, and spotted these in Forbidden Planet. We had rewatched Firefly the previous year, and loved it again, so I grabbed the two books; and then ran into the author herself at the ceremony, where she cheerfully signed them.

I confess that I had not actually got around to reading them until now, spurred by the fact that Una is the Guest of Honour at Novacon next weekend, but also they bubbled to the top of my reading lists anyway. One thing to say about both is that at the same time as reading them, I was also attempting to read one of the great classic Western novels set in the general area of Texas in the 1850s, and found the Firefly books so much more entertaining that I abandoned the other one. (More on that in due course.)

Second paragraph of third chapter of Firefly: Carnival:

“Trouble?” said Ava. She wasn’t anticipating trouble. She was heading off to the big city, like she’d always wanted to since Momma and Poppa had died. Free at last! Money in her pocket and all the big wide ‘verse to explore. “I’m a good girl! I ain’t plannin’ on gettin’ into trouble.”

This is set on a planet where the locals are preparing for Carnival, which means hedonistic enjoyment for the rich and hard work for the poor. The Serenity crew get tasked with the delivery of a sensitive cargo, which of course gets stolen from them, as a result of which their client holds Zoe and Shepherd Book hostage against its restitution. The crew also gets entangled with the story of 14-year-old Ava, who has left home to find her fortune in the city. Together they discover much more sinister goings-on, which the alert reader will work out before the characters do (in fairness because the characters are not able to share vital information between each other). We know from TV that human trafficking happens in the Firefly universe, and here we see how deeply it goes. You can get Firefly: Carnival here.

Second paragraph of Firefly: Coup de Grâce:

“Somethin’ the matter, Captain Reynolds?” I said. “Somethin’ you want to say to me?”

Here too there is a young woman at the centre of the story, the daughter of a lawyer who has been assassinated by a local gang. She hires the Serenity crew to get justice for her father, but the local politics turns out to be a lot more complex, with the gang enjoying a certain level of official and corporate protection. We end up exploring both the difficulties of post-conflict social and economic reconstruction, and there is vicious deconstruction of the Boris Johnson government’s “levelling-up” pledges. You can get Firefly: Coup de Grâce here.

Fans of the TV series will be very satisfied with either or both of these books. They both feature very good portrayals of the main cast, and interesting shuffling of the personalities to get pairings where the characters can banter off each other. I slightly get the sense that McCormack’s favourite is Simon Tan, but I may be wrong.

There are seven other Firefly novels, four by James Lovegrove and the others by Tim Lebbon, M.K. England and Rosiee Thor. I have read one book by Tim Lebbon and was on a 2005 Worldcon panel with James Lovegrove; perhaps I need to broaden out my Firefly reading.

Carnival and Coup de Grâce were the two SF books that had lingered longest unread on my shelves. Next on that pile will be Descendant Machine by Gareth Powell, but it will wait until I have finished all the other books I acquired in 2023. Carnival was also the top unread book on my shelves acquired in 2023. Next on that pile is Paul: The Pagans’ Apostle, by Paula Frederiksen.

This Sporting Life, and Peace in Our Time, by Una McCormack

Two Big Finish Short Trips, both by Una McCormack in advance of her Novacon appearance, both featuring the First Doctor and Steven (the first also with Dodo), both moored in real historical events, both read by Peter Purves. Both are audios, so I won’t attempt to locate the second paragraph of the third section in either case.

This Sporting Life, from 2016, is about the theft of the World Cup thirty years before. Stephen finds himself unexpectedly holding part of the trophy, and the TARDIS crew ends up entangled in a trail of stranded aliens and helpful humans, and the need to get history back onto the right course. The alien intrusion into our history is of course one of the classic Doctor Who plots, but nicely done here, and there are some good character moments for the unsporty Stephen, vs Dodo for whom this is contemporary history. The title of course refers to the 1963 film of the same name starring William Hartnell. You can get This Sporting Life here.

Peace in Our Time, from 2019, is also a story of alien intrusion, but this time it is evil extraterrestrials meddling with the Anglo-German naval arms race by infiltrating the Admiralty just before the launch of HMS Dreadnought in 1906, with the Doctor and Steven trying again to re-route history onto the correct lines. The interesting thing here is that the viewpoint character is Ruby Watkins, a servant in a posh house, who is a channel for McCormack’s observations about class and patriarchy, and ends up (minor spoiler) engaging with the suffragettes. It stretches a bit farther than This Sporting Life, which is not necessarily a bad thing. You can get Peace in Our Time here.

Picard: The Last, Best Hope, by Una McCormack

Second paragraph of third chapter:

During this brief pause, this hiatus before the whirl of activity that is about to follow, I must take a moment to remind myself how profoundly grateful I am to everyone who has willingly put aside everything to commit themselves to this mission. Above all, I thank the stars for the work done behind the scenes by my new XO, Commander Raffi Musiker. I am aware that through her efforts what should be problems are presented to me as wholly solved. Captain Kirsten Clancy has been liaising with the Romulans, and Raffi is of course a specialist in Romulan affairs. I have the distinct impression that Clancy’s tendency toward micromanagement has been a burden that my XO has also borne on my account, and I am greatly appreciative. This has left me with the time to fully concentrate on staffing, coordinating, and directing the fleet. On Earth, Commander Gbowee has rapidly constructed an organization and processes to respond to our requirements for matériel and staff; she and Lieutenant Kaul are masters of the concise briefing. Messages from Commander Geordi La Forge are proving an interesting read: I sense behind his words some resistance from the yard’s engineers at these new and overwhelming demands that are being placed upon them. I understand too that for many, this will mean setting aside research for many years that may well have been the chief concern. But if any officer can corral them toward a common goal, it is surely Geordi, among the most optimistic, practical, and sincere officers of my acquaintance.

This is the best known book by Una McCormack, according to the three book-logging systems that I consulted. Because Novacon is this weekend, and Una is the Guest of Honour, we’re going to have a run of her novels here this week.

It’s particularly poignant to be writing this so soon after we lost Sir Patrick Stewart. Of course, most of the best lines given to Picard were written by the writers, not him; but there has been a tremendously moving outpouring of affection from those who worked with him, or met him, or just even had a casual encounter with him in the supermarket queue (though I’m not sure that I believe the Huddersfield autograph story). We will not see his like again.

Back in pandemic days, we hugely enjoyed the first series of Picard. This is the prequel, telling the story of how Jean-Luc Picard masterminded the evacuation of the Romulans’ home world on assignment from the Federation. It’s not an action-packed adventure, but a thoughtful exploration of the politics of crisis, with a certain amount of putting narrative pieces in place to explain the setting of Picard.

McCormack folds into this some political parables: the Romulan refugee crisis feeds directly into populism and threats of Brexit-style secession within the Federation; there is a science-denying Romulan nobleman whose refusal to accept the imminent disaster puts his own people in danger. There’s also an interesting depiction of the tensions between secrecy and openness in Romulan society.

But the core of it is the character of Picard, who I think McCormack catches perfectly, and his trajectory from philosophically accepting his duty to losing patience with the Federation, via intermediary stages of indirectly or directly disobeying orders for the greater good. I think even a reader who knew nothing at all about Star Trek would enjoy this. You can get Picard: The Last, Best Hope here.

November 2008 books

In anticipation of the 25th anniversary of my bookblogging, which will come in late 2028, I’m reposting my monthly summaries since November 2003 when I started. (I already did this in 2019-2023, but this gives me a chance to consolidate all the posts and links to this WordPress site rather than my old Livejournal.) Everything will be linked under the bookblog nostalgia tag.

By great good chance I happened to be in New York during the first week of November 2008, 18 years ago this month, so I was able to witness at first hand the jubilation around Obama’s first election as President. It’s a nice coincidence for this month to come up now in my schedule of posts as we brace for the results of the mid-terms.

We also had a lovely weekend in Cambridge, marred however by the car breaking down on the Brussels ring road just as we were nearing home at 3.30 am.

Literally the following day, I went on one of my regular visits to Cyprus. I filmed a few streetscape shots of the northern part of Nicosia, with the intention of sharing them with work colleagues, but in the end was not satisfied with either the sound or the picture quality. Still, for posterity, here they are.

With transatlantic and Cyprus travels, I read 32 books in November 2008.

Non-fiction 8 (YTD 64)
Postwar: A History of Europe since 1945, by Tony Judt
Brussels versus the Beltway: Advocacy in the United States and the European Union, by Christine Mahoney
More Real Than Reality: The Fantastic in Irish Literature and the Arts, edited by Donald E. Morse and Csilla Bertha
Who Goes There (Travels through Strangest Britain, in Search of the Doctor), by Nick Griffiths
30 Hot Days, by Mehmet Ali Birand
Glafkos Clerides: the Path of a Country, by Niyazi Kızılyürek

Elizabeth I, by David Starkey
The Life of Elizabeth I, by Alison Weir

Non-genre 2 (YTD 24)
The Uncommon Reader, by Alan Bennett
Emma, by Jane Austen

Scripts 3 (YTD 19)
The Merchant of Venice, by William Shakespeare
The First Part of King Henry the Fourth, by William Shakespeare
The Second Part of King Henry the Fourth, by William Shakespeare

SF 13 (YTD 52)
The Adventures of Captain Underpants, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Attack of the Talking Toilets, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Invasion of the Incredibly Naughty Cafeteria Ladies from Outer Space (and the Subsequent Assault of the Equally Evil Lunchroom Zombie Nerds), by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Perilous Plot of Professor Poopypants, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Wrath of the Wicked Wedgie Woman, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Big, Bad Battle of the Bionic Booger Boy, Part 1: The Night of the Naughty Nostril Nuggets, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Big, Bad Battle of the Bionic Booger Boy, Part 2: The Revenge of the Ridiculous Robo-Boogers, by Dav Pilkey
Captain Underpants and the Preposterous Plight of the Purple Potty People, by Dav Pilkey

Year’s Best SF 13, edited by David G. Hartwell and Kathryn Cramer
Science Fiction Hall of Fame: The Greatest Science Fiction Stories of All Time, edited by Robert Silverberg
Heart of Stone, by C.E. Murphy
House of Cards, by C.E. Murphy
Hands of Flame, by C.E. Murphy

Doctor Who 4 (YTD 170)
Interference Book Two: The Hour of the Geek, by Lawrence Miles
Campaign, by Jim Mortimore
Doctor Who Annual [1966], [rumoured to be mainly written by David Whitaker]
Theatre of War, by Justin Richards

Comics 2 (YTD 6)
Burma Chronicles, by Guy Delisle
Alias vol 4: The Secret Origins of Jessica Jones, by Brian Michael Bendis

9,200 pages (YTD 85,300)
8/32 by women (YTD 47/355)
none by PoC (YTD 355)

I’m going to single out four good ones this month:

  • Who Goes There (Travels through Strangest Britain, in Search of the Doctor), by Nick Griffiths – a great book about looking for famous Doctor Who locations in England and Wales, while dealing with real life as well. You can get it here.
  • The Uncommon Reader, by Alan Bennett, a lovely little novella about Queen Elizabeth II suddenly deciding to start reading, and the viciously negative reactions of her advisers to her new habit. You can get it here.
  • The Science Fiction Hall of Fame: The Greatest Science Fiction Stories of All Time, edited by Robert Silverberg, one of those classic collections, assembling the top sf stories published before 1965 as voted for by the membership of SFWA in the late 1960s. You can get it here.
  • Alias vol 4: The Secret Origins of Jessica Jones, by Brian Michael Bendis and others; so many pages here where Bendis and the artists achieve statements that couldn’t be made in any other medium – the schooldays flashback, Jessica’s first encounter with other superheroes, and the unspoken parts of her conversations with her friends and lovers. You can get it here.

An Una McCormack checklist

Novacon is next weekend, with Una McCormack as Guest of Honour. You may not be fully aware of what she has done; writers of tier-in works do not always get the recognition that they deserve. She has published sixteen Star Trek novels, with a seventeenth coming out this month; seven Doctor Who novels, two Firefly novels, two in the shared Weird Space world set up by Eric Green, and a couple of short standalones, as well as more than a dozen short stories. She has also written at least eighteen Big Finish audios, a couple of Blake’s Seven and Star Cops plays and more. She is a critic as well; I list her monograph on a 1989 Doctor Who story below, and she has also edited essay collections on Doctor Who and Lois McMaster Bujold and a collection of meditations from Woman’s Hour.

I give you fair warning that every day of this coming week, this blog is going to feature a review of Una’s work that I have recently read / listened to, culminating with her not yet published Star Trek novel. In the meantime, here is a checklist of her work that I have previously reviewed or mentioned here, followed by the library sites’ ratings of her works as a whole.

Doctor Who novels

Doctor Who non-fiction

Star Trek fiction:

As contributor (fiction)

As contributor (audio)

As contributor (non-fiction)

And here is the compete list of her works as far as I can track them on Goodreads, LibraryThing and StoryGraph:

TitleAuthorGR
raters
LT
owners
SG
reviews
The PeacemakersStar Trek: Deep Space Ninenot published yet
The Last Best HopeStar Trek: Picard4,217328759
The Autobiography of Kathryn JanewayStar Trek: Voyager2,242158538
The Way Through the WoodsDoctor Who1,302241259
The King’s DragonDoctor Who1,144291216
CarnivalFirefly1,604145278
Cardassia and AndorWorlds of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine954319136
The Crimson ShadowStar Trek: The Fall1,169185165
The Never Ending SacrificeStar Trek: Deep Space Nine896216156
The Way to the StarsStar Trek: Discovery983110226
Enigma TalesStar Trek: Deep Space Nine935113216
Royal BloodDoctor Who821155171
BrinkmanshipStar Trek: Typhon Pact887150118
All Flesh is GrassDoctor Who: Time Lord Victorious84885197
Molten HeartDoctor Who58992202
The Undefeated(standalone)66878201
Hollow MenStar Trek: Deep Space Nine48621883
Coup de GrâceFirefly9398596
The Autobiography of Mr. SpockStar Trek60412683
AsylumStar Trek: Strange New Worlds68360127
The MissingStar Trek: Deep Space Nine60410382
WonderlandsStar Trek: Discovery52470110
Second SelfStar Trek: Picard8309422
CagedDoctor Who2632671
The Baba Yaga (with Eric Brown)Weird Space1385023
Window on the WorldDoctor Who931927
The Robot RevolutionDoctor Who732718
Gallifrey: Time War 1Doctor Who1181320
The Star of the SeaWeird Space772615
PartisansDoctor Who: Gallifrey901117
Doctor Who: Red PlanetsDoctor Who921016
The Good LifeDoctor Who: Master79422
The Curse of FenricDoctor Who: Black Archive:331310
Infidel PlacesTorchwood56414
This Sporting LifeDoctor Who62310
EvolutionGallifrey5239
An Eye for MurderDoctor Who17154
Peace in Our TimeDoctor Who4716
CounterstrikeDoctor Who2145
Impossible Worlds, Impossible Things: Cultural Perspectives on Doctor Who, Torchwood, and the Sarah Jane Adventures (co-edited with Ross Garner and Melissa Beattie)993
Ministry of TruthBlake’s 719190
The Shadow of This Red RockStar Cops1826
The Greatest Story Ever Told(standalone)11131
Biology and Manners: Essays on the Worlds and Works of Lois McMaster Bujold4103
Risk ManagementBlake’s 7264
Troubled WatersStar Cops1030
DeliveranceBlake’s 7820
Woman’s Hour: Daily Meditat…110
Short But Concentrated: an essay symposium on the works of Lois McMaster Bujold (ed with Regina Yung Lee)020
Short But Concentrated #2: an essay symposium on the works of Lois McMaster Bujold100

The best known books set in each country: Ireland

I usually start each of these posts with a quick pen-portrait of the country, to reassure confused readers who may not be certain where they are, but this seems unnecessary for Ireland.

See here for the methodology of these posts, though NB that I am now also using numbers from StoryGraph. Books are disqualified if less than 50% of them is set in the internationally recognized borders of Ireland (though in fact this did not make a difference).

These numbers are crunched by hand, not by AI.

TITLEAUTHORGR
RATERS
LT
OWNERS
SG
REVIEWS
Normal PeopleSally Rooney 2,011,83211,193303,072
The Guest ListLucy Foley 1,368,0817,916185,610
Angela’s Ashes Frank McCourt 670,71123,90835,071
Conversations with FriendsSally Rooney 636,9814,365122,375
In the Woods Tana French 456,91911,95950,221
Small Things Like TheseClaire Keegan 524,2064,64795,901
Beautiful World, Where Are YouSally Rooney 521,1604,00495,594
DublinersJames Joyce 186,73922,574233,46

When I did this exercise in 2015, the runaway winner was Angela’s Ashes on both Goodreads and LibraryThing. Of the other books on the above list, only In the Woods and Dubliners were available then; the other five have all been published since.

The winner is one of three novels by Sally Rooney on the list. Normal People, in case you don’t know, is the story of two young people falling in and out and back in love with each other while students at Trinity College Dublin. I know that some sneer at it, but personally I loved it, and also lapped up the TV series. It wins overall and also on Goodreads and StoryGraph, though was only fifth on LibraryThing.

I haven’t read Rooney’s Conversations with Friends, which is apparently about two young women who become involved with an older (but not the much older) couple; I have read Beautiful World, Where Are You, which is about a novelist and her editor friend and their lovers, and I was not as impressed.

Sally Rooney’s books are not currently on sale in the UK, for reasons expertly unpacked by David Allen Green here. Two Chinese friends separately told me in the last few weeks that her books are becoming popular there, so she can probably take the hit of losing the UK market for the time being.

The Guest List is a murder mystery set on an island off the Irish coast. It sounds very similar to the classic Agatha Christie novel now known as …And Then There Were None.

Angela’s Ashes still wins LibraryThing and is third on Goodreads (though only sixth on StoryGraph). It is a heart-rending tale of grinding poverty in Limerick in the 1920s and 1930s.

In the Woods is the first in the very successful Dublin Murder Squad series of mysteries. It was published in 2007.

Small Things Like These is about the Magdalen laundries, specifically in County Wexford.

Dubliners is probably my favorite book on the list, the classic collection of short stories by James Joyce, every one of them a jewel.

The StoryGraph numbers kicked Joyce’s Ulysses and A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man off the list, in favour of Small Things Like These and Beautiful World, Where Are You.

The only book that came close to troubling my geographical criteria was Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe, which is mainly set in Northern Ireland, but it was some way off on the numbers.

I normally list other books on my shelves set in or concerning the country of the week, but there are far too many of them this time.

Next up is New Zealand; then Costa Rica, Kuwait and Panama.

Asia: India | China | Indonesia | Pakistan | Bangladesh (revised) | Russia | Japan | Philippines (revised) | Vietnam | Iran | Türkiye | Thailand | Myanmar | South Korea | Iraq | Afghanistan | Yemen | Uzbekistan | Malaysia | Saudi Arabia | Nepal | North Korea | Syria | Sri Lanka | Taiwan | Kazakhstan | Cambodia | Jordan | UAE | Tajikistan | Israel | Laos | Turkmenistan | Kyrgyzstan | Hong Kong | Singapore | Lebanon | Palestine | Oman
Americas: USA | Brazil (revised) | Mexico | Colombia | Argentina | Canada | Peru | Venezuela | Chile | Guatemala | Ecuador | Bolivia | Haiti | Dominican Republic | Honduras | Cuba | Nicaragua | Paraguay | El Salvador | Costa Rica
Africa: Nigeria | Ethiopia (revised) | Egypt | DR Congo | Tanzania | South Africa | Kenya | Sudan | Uganda | Algeria | Morocco | Angola | Mozambique | Ghana | Madagascar | Côte d’Ivoire | Cameroon | Niger | Mali | Burkina Faso | Malawi | Zambia | Chad | Somalia | Senegal | Zimbabwe | Guinea | Benin | Rwanda | Burundi | Tunisia | South Sudan | Togo | Sierra Leone | Libya | Liberia | Mauritania
Europe: Russia | Türkiye | Germany | France | UK | Italy | Spain | Poland | Ukraine | Romania | Netherlands | Belgium | Sweden | Czechia | Azerbaijan | Portugal | Greece | Hungary | Austria | Switzerland | Belarus | Bulgaria | Serbia | Denmark | Norway | Finland | Slovakia | Ireland
Oceania: Australia | Papua New Guinea | New Zealand